Demo exclusivity causing a big stink

Latest works by souri
  • Rewriting old player movement code

    In my first and previous post in this game dev log entry, I had written that I wanted to do a game which was a collection of simple retro games. Unity released a new major release (2019.3) while I was putting the initial project together, and I…

  • Working on a small game to showcase the Devlog

    Well, I'm making a game . I'm spending the next few weeks on making a small game to showcase the gamedev log feature on tsumea where any member can create a game entry and other members can post journal posts with art, music or just development…

  • Just a test 2

    Just a test #2. Still working on the new section.

  • A long, long time ago, I was a pixel artist

    So, I got a Commodore 64 when I was in the 4th grade. It came bundled with a Rolf Harris picture building program on casette tape which never loaded properly but from what I could tell by its box cover, you could build pictures from a selection…

  • A time for change

    Yes, the site looks very different and I've had to prematurely switch to this new theme that I'm working on for a few reasons, the main one is that changing certain aspects of the site to fit the new theme will affect how the old one looks for…

  • Some of my olddddd work

    (this is just a test, please ignore this entry)

    Here is some of my old work.. the first pic is of a 3d model of a human head I was working on about 2 years ago in 3dsmax, using nurbs. If I had to do it again, I wouldn't model a head with…

I currently work for

Submitted by souri on
Forum
General Chat

You may have read about it on a few sites, but I thought I'd post something about this rather extraordinary incident.

Basically, Activision and Fileplanet have made a deal where Fileplanet have the exclusive rights to host the The Call of Duty demo, available only to their paying members for a week before it is released publicly. There's little chance of playing the demo unless you're a FP paying member, because the demo requires a key for activation.

I say this incident is extraordinary because of the backlash this deal has made. A fair few well known game websites have joined a *blacklist* of the demo once it does get a public release. The growing list of websites include 3D Downloads, 3D Gamers, AusGamers, Blue's News, Edge Files / Callofduty.org, FileFront, FileShack, Gamer's Hell, GameGossip, Loaded Inc Network, Tiscali Games, WorthPlaying. That's quite a list if you ask me - I only download demos from three places, and they're listed there.

There was a similar incident some time ago with the Raven Shield demo oon Fileplanet (legal threats were made to other websites that hosted it), and because of the public outcry then, the publisher released it the next day. I wonder what Activision will be doing in this case.

I do wonder what Activision does get out of an exclusivity deal like this though (apart from a quick buck). Getting gamers to pay (pony up the costs for membership at Fileplanet) to see your advertisement (demo)? Seems strange to me.

To read on why exclusivity deals hurt the gaming community, there's a good set of reasons listed on [url="http://www.shacknews.com/ja.zz?comments=28103"]shacknews[/url]..

Submitted by Brain on Sat, 30/08/03 - 1:00 AMPermalink

Mmm, it'll be interesting to see the outcome of this. I'm kind of thinking that Activision will have no choice but to give things up, as with the large list of sites blacklisting them, it won't favour on their publicity too well (apart from the whole "bad publicity is good publicity").

Always interesting to watch our industry form.

Submitted by Daemin on Sat, 30/08/03 - 5:00 AMPermalink

Well i don't see much of a problem by this from a business perspective, since if you're a game developer and you've got an arrangement where gamespy gives you its multiplayer tech in exchange for one week's exclusivity of your games demo, then that's a pretty damn good deal. And if you pay for the gamespy's fileplanet service, wouldn't you want some special content, so that you can have bragging rights and all that - "I've played it first!"?

Ahh well, I guess we're all a bunch of wingers in the end :-P

Submitted by Blitz on Sat, 30/08/03 - 7:11 AMPermalink

Yeah, think of all the free advertising they're losing not getting the demo hosted on those sites. Even if they get their multiplayer tech or whatever free, i think they'd be losing a s/load more in potential sales. And thats not even mentioning the bad reputation activision will get. Shunned!
CYer, Blitz

Submitted by Daemin on Sat, 30/08/03 - 9:32 AMPermalink

Well I'd say that most of the bitching is because those other sites make money from hosting demos, and if they aren't hosting the demo then they aren't making money etc - not as much as gamespy is making etc.

Submitted by souri on Thu, 04/09/03 - 8:32 AMPermalink

I've *finally* finished downloading the demo. Completed the demo within 10 minutes on medium level, though. Quite a nice game, there's plenty of atmosphere and intense action to be had (parachutes, planes, weapons fire into the air etc).. the art quality is pretty average, but I do love the player models and their animation. They climb over fences, duck, crawl, look around walls, sit down, check things out etc. It's cool to just watch your squad move out and make their way through.. And there's some hand gestures, mouth movements etc when that captain speaks. So yes, very well done character animation..

Posted by souri on
Forum
General Chat

You may have read about it on a few sites, but I thought I'd post something about this rather extraordinary incident.

Basically, Activision and Fileplanet have made a deal where Fileplanet have the exclusive rights to host the The Call of Duty demo, available only to their paying members for a week before it is released publicly. There's little chance of playing the demo unless you're a FP paying member, because the demo requires a key for activation.

I say this incident is extraordinary because of the backlash this deal has made. A fair few well known game websites have joined a *blacklist* of the demo once it does get a public release. The growing list of websites include 3D Downloads, 3D Gamers, AusGamers, Blue's News, Edge Files / Callofduty.org, FileFront, FileShack, Gamer's Hell, GameGossip, Loaded Inc Network, Tiscali Games, WorthPlaying. That's quite a list if you ask me - I only download demos from three places, and they're listed there.

There was a similar incident some time ago with the Raven Shield demo oon Fileplanet (legal threats were made to other websites that hosted it), and because of the public outcry then, the publisher released it the next day. I wonder what Activision will be doing in this case.

I do wonder what Activision does get out of an exclusivity deal like this though (apart from a quick buck). Getting gamers to pay (pony up the costs for membership at Fileplanet) to see your advertisement (demo)? Seems strange to me.

To read on why exclusivity deals hurt the gaming community, there's a good set of reasons listed on [url="http://www.shacknews.com/ja.zz?comments=28103"]shacknews[/url]..

Submitted by Brain on Sat, 30/08/03 - 1:00 AMPermalink

Mmm, it'll be interesting to see the outcome of this. I'm kind of thinking that Activision will have no choice but to give things up, as with the large list of sites blacklisting them, it won't favour on their publicity too well (apart from the whole "bad publicity is good publicity").

Always interesting to watch our industry form.

Submitted by Daemin on Sat, 30/08/03 - 5:00 AMPermalink

Well i don't see much of a problem by this from a business perspective, since if you're a game developer and you've got an arrangement where gamespy gives you its multiplayer tech in exchange for one week's exclusivity of your games demo, then that's a pretty damn good deal. And if you pay for the gamespy's fileplanet service, wouldn't you want some special content, so that you can have bragging rights and all that - "I've played it first!"?

Ahh well, I guess we're all a bunch of wingers in the end :-P

Submitted by Blitz on Sat, 30/08/03 - 7:11 AMPermalink

Yeah, think of all the free advertising they're losing not getting the demo hosted on those sites. Even if they get their multiplayer tech or whatever free, i think they'd be losing a s/load more in potential sales. And thats not even mentioning the bad reputation activision will get. Shunned!
CYer, Blitz

Submitted by Daemin on Sat, 30/08/03 - 9:32 AMPermalink

Well I'd say that most of the bitching is because those other sites make money from hosting demos, and if they aren't hosting the demo then they aren't making money etc - not as much as gamespy is making etc.

Submitted by souri on Thu, 04/09/03 - 8:32 AMPermalink

I've *finally* finished downloading the demo. Completed the demo within 10 minutes on medium level, though. Quite a nice game, there's plenty of atmosphere and intense action to be had (parachutes, planes, weapons fire into the air etc).. the art quality is pretty average, but I do love the player models and their animation. They climb over fences, duck, crawl, look around walls, sit down, check things out etc. It's cool to just watch your squad move out and make their way through.. And there's some hand gestures, mouth movements etc when that captain speaks. So yes, very well done character animation..